Saturday, August 17, 2013

The Gracious Bereaved: Why sincerity in our hearts trumps the stupidity of our words


In its early stages: Cute.

My friend explained it this way. The visitor had nearly exhausted her. Pancreatic cancer left her with significantly less stamina than the hour-long visit had required, even though the conversation was primarily a monologue as the visitor related a litany of her own difficulties in the areas of health, relationships, and finances. “At least she knew not to ask, ‘How are you?’” my friend said.

But when I offered my regrets that she had been subjected to all that, my dying friend stunned me. “It was nice to have someone come to visit me.”

In light of that, and some comments on the last two posts, let me reiterate a point or two. First, those things on the list of what not to say? They’re things that have really been said. (I’ve said some myself.) I share them frequently, to dispell your fear of saying the wrong thing. You will, of course. But that no matter how badly you stumble, others have said far worse…and survived.

As it progresses: Awkward.
A second restatement, from the first of these three posts, is that questions (Other than, “How are you?”) are better than statements. But even questions are often unnecessary. The bereaved and dying are often longing for someone to sit quietly and listen. Let them know you’re really there (and not looking for the first opportunity to run from the room), prompt them with a question or two if necessary, and listen. “Bearing silent witness to their suffering,” said a friend, “is sometimes all you can do. But it’s often everything they need.” To simply know that someone knows something of our pain can mean more than all the words of all the philosophers, theologians, and Helen Steiner Rice wannabees combined.

Understand, though, that one of the elements of grief is Anger. There are times when the outrage of disease, disability, and imminent death results in lashing out at even those closest to us, even our primary caregivers. Even in those moments, however, the importance of presence still overcomes ridiculously inept statements. And that’s not just because the bereaved and dying are desperate for company.

Ultimately: Incurable.
I was the one in the hospital bed. Widespread systems failures from an unknown cause left me attached to (and invaded by) most of the kinds of tubes and wires owned by Castleview Hospital in Price, Utah. I was conscious, and not terribly glad to be. No one from the congregation I served came to visit. My ministry supervisor, though, had called to assure me that the district office was praying for me. Still, I was feeling a bit desperate for company. But when a local ministry colleague arrived, he didn’t speak at first, clearly aghast at the sight. His eventual question was “How are you?” I managed not to respond verbally. (And it wouldn’t have been “Fine, and you?”)

But I was glad he came to visit. Admittedly, I was desperate for someone who was there to see me, rather than merely the charts, monitors, and reports in which my life had become enmeshed. So, despite incredulity at his question, I realized that I’d asked the same question just as inappropriately. I vowed there and then to try to stop.

And so the list was born. It’s up to “Fifty Things Not To Say to the Bereaved.” There will be more. I will keep showing up, listening, asking questions as necessary, and occasionally opening my mouth only to shock myself at how the sincerity of my heart can result in such stupidity in my words.

I hope not to presume too much upon it, but I do thank God for the graciousness of the bereaved. So far, none of them have thrown me out. And so I go, and listen, and ask questions as necessary, and pray that you find the courage to do the same.

Friday, August 16, 2013

Fifty Things Not To Say to the Bereaved



As I mentioned in my prior post, I’ve been compiling this list for some time. Others have written on the same theme, and you may have more to add to it. (I’d be grateful if you’d share, please.) I also know, from seminars and seminary classes I’ve taught, that not all of these are immediately clear to everyone. So, if you have questions or concerns about why a particular saying is on the list, please comment and I’ll try to explain concisely enough to fit into the space allowed. (And if you want a little more information on why I find this so important, the previous post, “Silence Is Rarely Golden, but the Alternative Is Often Mercurial,” is found here: http://deathpastor.blogspot.com/2013/08/silence-is-rarely-golden-but.html.)

Here’s what not to say:

1.       #1 – Nothing. (As in, don’t just say nothing.)
2.       Close Second – I know how you feel.
3.       How are you doing? (Unless you are sure you have the time to hear the answer.)
4.       It’s for the best. (Or, “It’s probably for the best.”)
5.       At least you still have…(your other children/your health/your youth/your other parent).
6.       Don’t forget you have others who need you. (esp., “Don’t forget your other children need you.”)
7.       You’ll meet someone else eventually.
8.       They wouldn’t want you to be sad/crying/depressed/angry/alone/etc.
9.       It’s not your fault.
10.    They’re in a better place.
11.    It was just their time to go.
12.    You’re strong enough to deal with this.
13.    You can put this behind you and get on with your life.
14.    God needed them in heaven.
15.    How long did the doctor say you have?
16.    Are you feeling any better yet?
17.    They’ll always be with you in your heart.
18.    I’m sorry I brought it up.
19.    You’re still young; you can (have another child/get remarried/etc.).
20.    Cheer up.
21.    It was God’s will.
22.    You’ll get over this.
23.    You were only a little-bit pregnant, right? It’s not like you lost a CHILD.
24.    It was/wasn’t meant to be.
25.    Look at how much you have to be thankful for.
26.    You’ll want to have someone around for awhile.
27.    They’re much happier now.
28.    Nothing will change the love you had for each other.
29.    God had another plan.
30.    I’ve had a similar experience…
31.    I can’t imagine what would have made them commit suicide.
32.    They had a full life.
33.    It’s time you started to move on with your life.
34.    Something good always comes out of tragedy.
35.    They’re no longer suffering.
36.    Call me if there’s anything you need.
37.    You know, the scripture teaches…
38.    You had a good long marriage/life with them.
39.    There, but for the grace of God, go I.
40.    Don’t cry/say that/feel that way.
41.    You couldn’t have known.
42.    Let’s change the subject.
43.    Everything happens for a reason.
44.    This, too, shall pass.
45.    We’ll always be here for you.
46.    Be glad he was _____, and not ______. (“5 mos, not 5 years,” “85 and not 45,” etc.)
47.    You should be glad they went quickly. (Or, “You should be glad they had time to put things in order.”)
48.    Any comparisons with anyone else’s losses.
49.    “You’ll be the youngest person we’ve ever had in long-term care.”
50.    To a teacher whose due-date would have been near the beginning of the school year, had she not miscarried: “At least this way you can plan the timing better next time.” (The teacher’s response: “After three miscarriages, I’ll take a baby on whatever schedule I can get one.”)

Thursday, August 15, 2013

Silence Is Rarely Golden, but the Alternative Is Often Mercurial



Loading mercury with a pitchfork
   your truck is almost full. The neighbors
   take a certain pride in you. They
        stand around watching.
-Richard Brautigan

Mercury is difficult to handle (especially with a pitchfork, as Richard Brautigan understood), and dangerous as well. The potential for damage to yourself or others recommends we avoid it if at all possible.

That’s how many of us feel about talking to the bereaved. And so we opt for silence. I hope to change that.

A good friend, socially-adept, mutually acquainted with a couple enduring incredible distress, explained again last week that he had not called or visited them. “I don’t know what I would say,” was his well-reasoned motivation. Others have felt the need to say something, anything, and with unfortunate results. Those facing great difficulties, especially bereavement (“having experienced a significant loss, usually through the death of a loved one”), hear some truly amazing things.

If our words might be damaging, then silence should be the safer choice…except that it’s deadly. The echo of the past often deafens those in grief and mourning, disabling them from hearing a balance of the valued relationship and the reality of its loss. It helps to speak aloud past memories, along with today’s grief. But if all their friends are more fearful of speaking than they are of silence, they sit alone, searching for signs of continuity in their lives.


For a moment, imagine yourself speaking to a friend who has experienced a significant loss—and as you realize that you don’t know what you might say, consider also that silence is among the least effective alternatives. “But I might say the wrong thing.” Yes. That’s very true. In fact, those who are sure they know “the right thing to say” are often oblivious to how wrong they are. So, I would like to offer you two tools I find helpful.

Since one of the most helpful activities of mourning is reminiscence, the first tool is to simply go and listen. Simple questions are most helpful in starting the process. I serve many bereaved individuals and families. Most of them I am meeting for the very first time in the midst of one of their least-social moments. I ask, “What should I know about your circumstances that would help me serve you best?” For closer friends, I have asked, “What have you found yourself thinking about?” or “What are you feeling today?” (Remember, “How are you feeling?” suggests they tell us, “Fine, thanks.”) It doesn’t take much to start the conversation.

Second, though, since even when we’re committed to asking simple questions and then simply listening, there are so many things that sound so right…until we actually say them. I have found it helpful to catalog “The Wrong Things to Say.” So, if it helps motivate you to go and listen, then I’ll gladly share that list with you, so that you at least have a map of as much of the mine-field of well-intentioned platitudes as I’ve discovered so far. (I just learned a new one last Friday. It’s a beaut! You’ll find it at the end of the list I'll be posting next.)

‘Til then, I remain…

Your servant for Jesus’ sake (II Corinthians 4:5),

Wm. Darius Myers, Death Pastor